A Valentine’s Prohibition Era (SOLD OUT) Murder Mystery Dinner

SATURDAY, FEBRUARY 18, 2023 AT 5:30 PM – 8:30 PM

The Hillcrest Estate
1940 Craig Rd, Pavilion, NY, United States, New York

Join us for a night of live interactive dinner theatre!

It’s 1923 and legitimate businessman, Lucky is bringing his wife to our Valentines Day Celebration. His two henchman: his “close” female friend and an underworld gambler in debt to him will also be in attendance. Will Lucky’s luck run out? Surely nothing could go wrong at our Love Day Celebration at the Hillcrest Estate?

Doors open and cash bar begins at 5:30pm. The dinner buffet and interactive show will begin at 6pm. Dinner will include: chicken French, sliced BBQ sirloin, red skin mashed potatoes, baked mozzarella penne, roasted vegetable medley, salad and rolls. The cash bar will be available throughout the evening. Dessert will be served later in the evening.

The show will end at 8pm and after-dinner coffee will be made available. The winning team (aka. table) who solves the murder will receive a prize!

Tickets are limited and this event is expected to sell out quickly! Please send any special requests for dinner seating if your tickets were purchased separately from a larger group.

The Hillcrest Estate has four bedrooms available for overnight accommodations and one carriage house on property (with two bedrooms). Please inquire with Kate at or 585.356.7164 if you’d like to stay overnight at The Hillcrest Estate after the event!

Who's Wine Oct 2021

Lighthouse Death & Taxes

Railway PosterInfringe Poster 2021

William Morgan Poster 2020Hidden Valley Poster Price UpdatedHalloween Comfort Zone3No Goal ShowWilliam Morgan Poster updated priceShips Poster PD DanceInfringe Poster 2019grapes of laugh updatedMaiden's Proposal Updated2historical showcircus showletter sized wine posterA Wedding On The CliffMurder at the MobsRoycroft PosterStar Wars Poster Sept. 22Infringe Poster 2018Death on the Downhill Postergolf posterMaker Faire Postervalentines dayHalloween Second ShowMug & MusketHalloween Murder Mysteryinfringement poster